r/geography Jun 16 '26

META Crackdown on low-quality and unhelpful comments

564 Upvotes

Hello users of [r/geography](r/geography),

Recently, this subreddit has become a lot more popular on Reddit. However, many of our long-time users have been leaving the subreddit due to a very specific and repeated complaint.

There are too many low-quality and unhelpful comments that, rather than aiming to help the OP, exist solely to make tired and repetitive jokes for karma.

From now on, practically all comments of this sort will be deleted, and repeat offenders will be banned for 14 to 30 days. I could give many examples of this, but some of the most common ones are "If my grandma had wheels, she'd be a bicycle" under any post asking about hypothetical changes and yo mama jokes.

In addition to this, we have received many complaints about posts that could theoretically be open to the entire world, but the way they are worded is extremely American-centric for no necessary reason, making people from other countries feel left out and like they can't contribute. From now on, these posts will be deleted. This also applies to posts for any country, we just see it about the United States most often.

To clarify, if somebody wants to ask about a specific geographic feature located in the United States, those posts are completely fine. But posts such as "Which city in the United States has the best beaches?" or "Which American state has the most scenic mountains?" will be removed, as will posts like "Which Canadian city has the worst drivers?" or "Which European country has the nicest people?". In general, the aim is for this subreddit to discuss geography, not just "facts about countries", which is better suited for the various Ask subreddits (AskAnAmerican, AskEurope, AskTheWorld, etc)

We would also like to crackdown on bot posts but that is very hard. Unortunately, most traffic on Reddit is bots nowadays. If anybody has any ideas, please comment below.

Feel free to express your opinion on this. Thank you!

EDIT: After feedback, I have edited part of this post.


r/geography 7h ago

Question How was Hungary-Romania border defined?

Post image
638 Upvotes

There are no physical barriers that can define the border, and it can't be entirely based on ethnographic principle since population is mixed on both sides, and it can't be economic since Transylvania was mostly linked to Budapest by imperial railroad. So I wonder what was guiding treaty makers?


r/geography 11h ago

Discussion Which of these proposed binational or intranational bridges/tunnels is most likely to be built?

Post image
965 Upvotes

Also, which is the least likely to be built? Ideally, which would offer the greatest overall benefits if completed, and which would offer the least benefits? Realistically, which would be the most beneficial and which would be the most catastrophic if built? Consider factors such as geography, engineering feasibility, economic cost and benefits, and political relationships between the regions involved.


r/geography 7h ago

Map When your embassy is next door to home

Post image
368 Upvotes

r/geography 20h ago

Question Why is most of Australia a desert despite being surrounded by oceans? Could it realistically create a large, self-sustaining forest in the interior?

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

r/geography 4h ago

Question Am I the only one who had a strange hyperfixation with lost continents

Post image
113 Upvotes

These were so interesting to me because I always wondered what would be special about them that we would never know like their culture, people, and land


r/geography 22h ago

Question Why does it seem like the deserts follows the Tropic of Cancer but going past the middle east gets pushed further up North?

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/geography 1d ago

Map The longest possible straight-line journey by sea is from Russia to Pakistan, covering over 20,000 miles.

Post image
5.7k Upvotes

r/geography 19h ago

Image OC. Outside of Moab Utah

Post image
906 Upvotes

What makes this turquoise color in the rocks?


r/geography 1d ago

Question Why did Texas give up this land in the Missouri Compromise of 1850 despite it being below 36°30N?

Post image
591 Upvotes

Does it have to do with Spanish settlers?


r/geography 19h ago

GIS/Geospatial The Butterfly Demo

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

219 Upvotes

Location: 49.0987954416N, 1.640249982E

Watch it full screen!

This demonstrates Hex9 - a near equal-area hierarchical hexagonal grid (DGGS), using it's own octahedral projection ('butterfly') and starting at Layer 0 (12 hexagons) - zooming into Layer 25. Hex9 goes up to Layer 30 or more - but I ran out of imagery.

The entire engine is available to make your own.

Or you can use it for data sampling, partitioning, geotagging.. you name it.

This demo uses the classic hex9 label - but it also supports a full Moore-type (closed) sphere-filling loop with the full Hilbert package — substitution self-similarity, prefix-nesting indices, consecutive cells always adjacent, range-query clustering within ~4% of the classical square-grid Hilbert.

Enjoy! And visit the arboretum some day!

....and every single pixel is a coloured hexagon on the grid.


r/geography 20h ago

Discussion How come west africa was able to develop centralized nation states and cities despite living in the savana while west and south africa didn't?

Post image
199 Upvotes

How come west africa was able to develop centralized nation states and cities despite living in the savana while East and south africa didn't?


r/geography 11h ago

Question What’s the reason (if any) that the Dnieper and Don River’s follow a very similar “S” shape?

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/geography 22h ago

Map The Mountains of North America

Post image
263 Upvotes

I feel like a lot of the maps I could find online omit a lot of the minor but still quite expansive mountain ranges that are found in North America so I wanted to take a stab at making map myself.

What would you add/remove/relabel?


r/geography 4h ago

Question Was there a regional name for West Africa before colonial times?

8 Upvotes

In my own research the closest thing I found was Dar al Sudan but that's both far broader and coming from the Arab perspective not a local one. Was there too much separation between the coast Niger river Savana and Lake nations for one term to emerge?


r/geography 1d ago

Discussion Peninsulas of Eurasia 5 : India

Post image
266 Upvotes

Where does it begin? Line, Mountains, Rivers. I say line.

Any photos to share or anything geographical about india feel free.


r/geography 17h ago

Discussion Could the Birth Rate of the PRC Still Be over the Replacement Rate if the One Child Policy Wasn't Implemented?

Post image
45 Upvotes

After the One Child Policy was implemented in the PRC in 1979, the birth rate plumetted despite it rising slightly in 2016 and 2021 (due to the implementation of the Two Child Policy and Three Child Policy).

Despite no policy for maximum ammount of children is in place now, the PRC still has more deaths than births.

Therefore, could the PRC's birth rate be over replacement in none of these policies were implemented?


r/geography 1d ago

Question Why is the smoke from the forest fires seemingly just “going around” Sudbury, Ontario?

Post image
7.2k Upvotes

r/geography 1d ago

Discussion Time zone squatters shouldn't complain about DST

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
423 Upvotes

r/geography 22h ago

Discussion why are south african savana so underpopulated and never formed any city?

Post image
19 Upvotes

more specifically why is the central part of tanzania and kenya so under popuated. and why did the the people of the south african savanna like the zulu and the Maasai never formed cities


r/geography 1d ago

Physical Geography A Groenlândia é a maior ilha do mundo que não é considerada um continente

Post image
219 Upvotes

r/geography 1d ago

Meme/Humor The worldle map for today ☠️

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

They are not playing around


r/geography 2d ago

Physical Geography This bend in the Rhine (Germany) creates a microclimate that shouldn't exist at this latitude

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

Just west of Frankfurt (at Wiesbaden), the Rhine does something it almost never does for 1,200+ km: it turns and flows west instead of north for about 25 kilometers, forced by the Taunus mountain range.

Normally a river valley at the Rhine would mean both banks get roughly equal sun exposure. But because of this specific bend, the entire northern bank ends up facing due south. Add the river acting as a giant light-reflecting mirror onto the slopes, plus the Taunus blocking cold northern wind, and it adds up: according to the Hessian State Agency for Nature Conservation, Environment and Geology (HLNUG), which recorded data from 1901-2025, the Rheingau averages 10.2°C, compared to 9.3°C in Giessen, a nearby town at the same elevation. That's a consistent, measurable 1°C+ difference driven entirely by this geographic quirk.

That 1-2°C is the entire reason the Rheingau became one of the most valuable wine regions in the world, first cultivated by Cistercian monks starting in 1136, who recognized the anomaly and engineered the slopes for viticulture. Today bottles from cellars they built sell for over 9,000 euros at auction.

I made a short documentary exploring the geography and history behind this in more depth, happy to share the link if anyone's interested: https://youtu.be/cbdi-eeLKBA

I think it's a great example of how a small physical accident can shape centuries of human land use.


r/geography 1d ago

Question Why is the smoke avoiding Peterborough & Parry sound Ontario ?

Post image
317 Upvotes

r/geography 1d ago

Map Why does Norway’s coastline become so deeply indented with fjords compared with Sweden’s?

Post image
574 Upvotes