r/personalfinance • u/sedona71717 • 14h ago
Insurance Someone is trying to scam me in an auto insurance claim
Edit: Thank you all for your advice— you have reassured me a great deal. For those asking if this is real or engagement bait, it is absolutely real and I’m pretty sure this policyholder is one of the dumbest humans on the planet. It’s also dumbfounding that their insurer would pay for the repairs with zero investigation. I’ll update this thread whenever this is resolved.
Long story short: I rear ended someone at a stop sign going about 5 mph. My airbag deployed (responding police said that can happen at slow speeds under certain conditions). The airbag gave me a concussion and I wasn’t thinking clearly, so I did not get out to take photos of the other car. I could see their bumper had minimal or no damage. EMS came, I went to the hospital.
Anyway, these people were driving a 2021 Mercedes. The police report clearly documented it with license plate and VIN. They waited 6 weeks and then filed a claim with my insurer for extensive damage in spots all over the car— but it was a 2026 BMW. Their insurer went ahead and paid the auto repair place immediately without investigating— before they even filed with my insurance — and the repairs were completed. My insurance is refusing the claim because that car wasn’t in the accident. Their insurance is sending me threatening letters, demanding I pay out of pocket $8,000 in repairs for a car I didn’t damage.
My insurer is telling me not to worry about it. I am worried about it. I don’t want my credit wrecked.