r/okbuddycinephile 23h ago

Recasts that were so smooth that you didn't even notice?

Post image
16.0k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

138

u/HalalMead 21h ago

Very sneaky one

84

u/reCaptchaLater 18h ago

5

u/Ambitious_Two3431 12h ago

Lmao I literally googled if they replaced him because I was genuinely upset about it.

85

u/Green_Insect_6455 19h ago

This ones weird, he said he got super self-conscious about how "fat" he had become in the role, and how "awful" he looked. So screw character continuity he decided he needed to be fit, and subsequently looked like he became anorexic by season 5. I was legit worried about his health which is why I even looked around at interviews.

Really odd because hes a god damn beefcake (complimentary) in the first few seasons. Doesnt look like an unhealthy weight by any means. Versus looking incredibly unhealthily skinny? Goes to show how deep the behind the scenes body shaming is in hollywood to this day.

42

u/yayiff 19h ago

I dunno whats up with this shows behind the scenes culture because MM's actor looked fine. Same with starlights actor who looked like a runway model but still didn't think she looked good and took a bunch of plastic surgery to turn herself into a Barbie doll.

What's with good looking actors in the boys needing to push themselves?

-4

u/iLoveDinosaurs1 16h ago

Y'all gotta get off of Erin Moriarty's case she had Grave's disease. And MM's actor was feeling bad about his weight because at his biggest in season 2 he took on a bunch of weight during covid by ordering in food all the time and he didn't wanna put his health at risk so he decided to lose the weight. You're so focused on how they looked on screen but they're human beings who decided to DO something for health reasons.

15

u/TheSerpentDeceiver 12h ago

You guys keep bringing up her Graves’ disease excuse without asking yourselves if that makes any sense. I’ve known multiple people with hyperthyroidism and none had tens of thousands of dollars in plastic surgery as a side effect.

28

u/FellowTraveler69 16h ago

Graves disease doesn't make your face immobile and hollow out the fat in your cheeks. She got bad plastic surgery in addition to whatever she was going through medically.

-13

u/One-Cardiologist4780 18h ago

Starlight also has an autoimmune disorder like Selena Gomez that makes her face blow up at different times. Iirc she only got her lips done

17

u/ArrrRawrXD 16h ago

Not true at all, they have completely different diseases, Erin Moriarty has Graves' disease which does not make her look like a plastic Barbie doll. At most it can affect how the eyes look like or lead to weight loss, but not give you buccal fat removal.

She absolutely did not only get her lips done

10

u/PM_ME_SOME_ANY_THING 18h ago

I was also wondering if he was sick or something. I guess an eating disorder is probably better than cancer or something.

2

u/ShinyVenusaur 17h ago

Not much better. Eating disorders have an insanely high mortality rate compared to other mental illnesses. It’s not stage 4 cancer but anorexia nervosa has an over 500% increased mortality rate compared to the avg pop. It ranks   behind opioid substance abuse (roughly every 10 ppl that die from opioid abuse, 2 die from eating disorders, 1 of which from anorexia nervosa) 

10

u/Office_Zombie 18h ago

The least he could have done was keep his facial hair the same.

The change was jarring and I almost would have preferred a recast.

4

u/myLongjohnsonsilver 12h ago

Something in the water at that show. The woman playing Starfire got some fucked body image issues too and fucked her face up.

Legitimately sad because both of them were damned fine as they were and now just look sickly.

3

u/MyNuts2YourFistStyle 13h ago

He probably had to start laying off the performance enhancers for health reasons.

3

u/Christmas_Elvis 11h ago

His personality changed completely with the weight loss too

3

u/ArrrRawrXD 16h ago

Versus looking incredibly unhealthily skinny

He does not, tf?

-5

u/Green_Insect_6455 16h ago

He does to me. Are you telling me Im wrong about my perception of health? 

Keep in mind Im a doctor

2

u/ArrrRawrXD 16h ago

Are you telling me Im wrong about my perception of health?

If you think he looks unhealthily skinny then yes, you are absolutely wrong. He's 6 feet and about 200 pounds, was 250 before and said he got too overweight during covid and that's why he decided to lose it.

3

u/Reda_E 19h ago

Just joining to say, I had a very physical job before and was a "beefcake" and it takes a toll on knees etc, that's just my thoughts about it though.

I agree with you though the transformation is uncanny.

Edited: "had instead of have"

7

u/Green_Insect_6455 19h ago

Well he didnt say anything like that, he talked like he thought he was some slovenly lump of fat. No mention of any legitimate health concerns, just seeing himself on posters and hating how "big" he looked.

3

u/Reda_E 19h ago

A okey I get it, that's a shame.

1

u/Toadalinakong 17h ago

To be fair in season 5 it makes sense and has a lore reason. Bro was getting depressed in prison camp for a whole year 

2

u/Green_Insect_6455 16h ago

To be fair thats not the reason that the change was made. Its a happy coincidence that allows you to headcanon away the real life uncomfortableness of the situation.

21

u/Valentils 19h ago

mother's milk vs oat milk

13

u/LoudNoise1234 19h ago

Mothers milk vs fathers milk

5

u/Jawnyblaze1 18h ago

I had just assumed he had some sort of health problem like Starlight. He might look even worse than her in the last season or two.

5

u/dev_vvvvv 17h ago

He went from looking like he was in his 30s (he was 45) to looking like he was in his 50s (his actual age). Bizarre.

2

u/HawkHarder 8h ago

Lol this was what I was going to say too. Still not convinced it's the same guy.

1

u/Zack_of_Steel 11h ago

I legit thought it was a different actor until I checked the credits.

-1

u/WiseCat293 11h ago

I didn’t like MM, in the first season, then I saw an interview where he talked in Spanish and he is Cuban?, after that he became my favorite character