r/gaming 3h ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

12.1k Upvotes

863 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

44

u/Japnzy 3h ago

Go back amd play some old JRPGs on ps1/2. Circle is ok and X is cancel.

Its fucking insane.

55

u/stipo42 3h ago

Because it makes more sense from a symbolic standpoint.

Circle the thing you want, cross off the things you don't want

11

u/JimboTCB 2h ago

X marks the spot, O is nothing

Either way round "makes more sense", it's entirely a matter of cultural context.

3

u/satsuppi 1h ago

also japanese way of marking answer. where O is correct and / is wrong..

1

u/Kaleidoscope-360 55m ago

Then they shouldn't have had "yes" be red and "no" be blue.

-2

u/shmimey 1h ago

Except you're wrong because zero is off for most power switchs made for electronics. So zero is not the thing I want to select most of the time since it is the off switch.

11

u/60Dan06 2h ago

Japan has it to this day, while the rest of the world uses it differently. But it makes sense, circle the correct thing, cross out the unvanted thing.
In their culture circle is used way more than for example ✅

2

u/afamiliarspirit 1h ago

Do they still have it that way in Japan? I thought I remembered a thing a few years ago where Sony made an effort to standardize it at least around their software.

1

u/InstitutionalizedOat 1h ago

The PS4 I have is that way. I assume it’s still most common in Japan

1

u/afamiliarspirit 1h ago

It was going into the PS5 generation that this changed is what I read.

1

u/InstitutionalizedOat 1h ago

Interesting. Don’t really have much interest in buying a PS5 but maybe I’ll check next time I see one on display

35

u/ogorangeduck 3h ago

Makes more sense based on what ⭕ and ❌ tend to signify

11

u/Rufus_Bojangles 3h ago

That always made more sense to me. A circle is like a universal symbol for positive/confirmation, while X usually denotes a negative. But it's nice when games give you the choice to switch them around.

1

u/Urdar 1h ago

Checkboxes are often "crossed" to select the option.

Its extremely culutrally dependent on what is felt to be more normal, and sony flet to mark something (with a cross) was the more prevelent norm in the west.

5

u/Malt129 3h ago

The MGS games had that but you were allowed to switch. Actually the old JRPGs also let you switch buttons.

1

u/Personal-Agent846 2h ago

Sonic Heroes. I always thought that was weird.

1

u/polo421 2h ago

Maybe that was a jrpg thing (which I didn't play) but most of the original ps2 games definitely used Y as back or cancel and that gets me all the time.

1

u/TheGoldblum 1h ago

That’s how PlayStation is in Japan at a system level. It’s always been that way and actually makes way more sense when you think about it. They also commonly use O’s instead of ticks in Japan

1

u/ILQGamer 3h ago

I emulate some old PS1 and 2 games from time to time, always have to do a double take with select being O and X being cancel. This and movement using D-pad are jarring

2

u/Crazy_Dave0418 2h ago

This and movement using D-pad are jarring

I mean at the time. The PS1 controller was just a glorified Snes controller with grips.

0

u/rogersdbt 3h ago

Makes way more sense tbh

0

u/Nervous-Fennel3325 2h ago

This only applies to pal games because in the usa X is confirm and O is cancel. One of the few games that does the opposite that tripped up everyone is Metal Gear Solid.

Been playing ps2 since it came out in NTSC.